Ponderings over the Slaughtering of 300,000 Pigs - Instablogs
Ponderings over the Slaughtering of 300,000 Pigs
Sarah , Cairo: May 7 2009
Made Popular May 7 2009
Egypt :

Ponderings over the Slaughtering of 300,000 Pigs

I thought long and hard over this one and I can safely say I thought Egypt was flipping out a little when it came to the reaction undertaken towards the whole swine flu panic that hit the world.

Completely eradicate an entire species from the country? Destroy a palpable industry that clearly is the livelihood of so many already below the poverty liners? Start this entire universal finger pointing face covering laughter stifling reaction after we had just come out of the whole Gaza thing! Risk what is known as the Garbage Village starting demonstrations or even considering strikes which would eventually leave Cairo drowning in Garbage in a matter of days?

Well, they had to have more than a few compelling reasons to do it, I thought. I don’t necessarily have that much faith in their decision making abilities or rational, but here’s the thing..this over reaction has been justified by the government officials using the lamest and least convincing arguments..

“If Swine flu spreads in Egypt more than 18 million could be at risk”...although the 6% fatality rate that has been put aside for the swine flu would total to like 4.8 million.

“People must understand that the slaughter order has nothing to do with the Swine flu”...urm, no comment on that one..Anyways, here’s my take on all this...

The contamination risk of this flu in this country would be frightening, I mean bird flu was one thing, and human-human contamination was not a certainty, while bird-human was. But with swine flu, if ONE garbage worker gets the flu, which he will naturally decide is JUST a flu, I would honestly be scared.
ONE garbage worker living and working amongst an estimated 60,000 - 70,000, working days, door to door service, gives the disease an exposure rate that scares me!

With every door to door service he conducts, an entire family is then at risk, and then the other members the family is in contact with, ranging from entire schools that the children go to, universities, and the work place, and ofcourse, each and every one of the 60 or 70 thousand who actually live in the same place as Swine Flu-er #1.

Honestly, and objectively (i admit perhaps not very logically) if this thing starts here, Egypt is fu**ed!
Taking it from another spin, even with the amount of people who could get infected, they still have a 94% survival chance. Sure, but! Within this percentage, we do not have the medical capacities, preparations, technologies nor stamina, to handle any of these consequences. Our hospitals will not be hygienic enough, nor organized enough, nor safe enough, nor quick enough, nor smart enough, nor alert enough to absorb any dimension of this virus.

Which would eventually take a much uglier media-frenzy phase than the one we think we’re currently experiencing. This is when Egypt would truly be subjected to humiliation and scrutiny and criticism and probably SHOCK from the entire world. The government would look sooo bad, that it could just trigger much bigger things, one of which is never a too far fetched idea in the minds of the more conspiracy-loving, like a coup!

I honestly don’t think the government cares about the 18 million at risk, hell it would be better for the entire country if we’re 20 million less. I don’t think the government really cares about the people’s health or safety...but in reality, the government must care about itself, and this would reflect really badly on the entire cabinet if it gets out of hand, because it WILL, and very quickly, uncover so much incompetency it will be the joke of the century.

So are the 300,000 little piggies worth it?

Ponderings over the Slaughtering of 300,000 Pigs

I do feel especially bad for the people who depend on this industry for a living. They are already living in unlivable conditions, they are already some of the poorest in the country, they are already some of the sickest, unhealthiest, malnutritioned and neglected group of people. They truly will suffer from this call, they will lose so much money, and they will bare so much MORE anger and bitterness.

As much as I would have liked for the reaction to be of a little more controlled-environmental nature...it isn’t. There’s no control in this virus’s spread, and so I guess there’s no controlled way of going about containing it.

Sure many conspiracies surfaced, even to the point where some decided that the virus was doctored and expected and that the universal economic crisis was the result.

Some more locally oriented thought this was all a conspiracy against the garbage workers to start eliminating their business to give way to private garbage companies.

Some accused the Pope of Alexandria to be in on it too..
Some took it to the Joos, and some pitched it to Islam being ever-so holier than thou!

Whatever, who’s really to know what’s a conspiracy and what’s utter paranoia? The facts are facts, and the fact is, weighing all of this, I don’t mind their over reaction on this one. I don’t mind it at all...

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Kyle
Ca, United States
Those Muslims in Egypt sure are peaceful people...
1 Stars
Mona A
cairo, Egypt
yeah blame it on the mouslims as usual.
1 Stars
Ok that actually made me laugh. I heard a few days ago a Swine Flu expert on one of the daily shows, I’m not sure I think it was John Stewart, related the slaughter order to the government trying to come down hard on the 10% Christian minority. She stated it like it was an actual fact, which, well, it might be, but it isn’t.
Doesn’t really have much to do with the ’muslims’ at this point.
1 Stars
Max
Mexico City, Mexico
Wasteful and stupid.

The disease does not come from eating pork, and the flu is contagious between humans at this point.
1 Stars
Bill
Portland, United States
Im no vegetarian, I love meat. But this seems like a sad waste to me, not to mention stupid. How do these guys not know its human-to-human now? I'd almost say its more of a religious move, taking advantage of the situation to prevent the consumption of pigs by the non muslim minority.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Probably right! But listen, we’re talking about some of the poorest hygienic atmospheres here. Disease that would probably kill swine flu! lol.
So it’s not about EATING the pork, as much as it’s herding the pigs that worry them. But that’s ofcourse if i’m going to pretend like the government actually gives a fu**! But the non-muslim minority has been consuming pig products for a very very long time, and it’s not like a secret underground supply chain either, you can find it in stores in certain places and openly and publicly, and some restaurants even serve it as an optional additional dressing (e.g. Pizza)
So anyways, if I know a thing or two about the kind of tension between the two sects in Egypt, I’d say the Muslims would be glad that the Non-muslims eat pork and so surely will go to hell. i.e. Good riddance!
1 Stars
Branesva
Birmingham, United Kingdom
they did the same thing with chickens during the whole bird flu scare. Apparently they just love slaughtering animals and ruining people's livelihoods at the drop of a hat.
2 Stars
Tiaan
Pretoria, South Africa
Let's kill all people to stop AIDS while we're at it.
(Global Perspectives)
3 Stars
Kiesty
Sydney, Australia
This is what happens when religious "people" run your science programs.

Expert medical advice!
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Hey killing the birds was the ONLY option! You’re talking about sick infected birds running around on house roofs and even INSIDE the homes. Kids playing with them, helping collect eggs, mothers feeding the chicken, unsanitary by ALL measures, and people in Egypt are still dying of bird flu today!!
It’s not about slaughtering animals. True it affects people’s livelihoods but some people who owned chicken farms and raised domestic chickens here would rather keep their sick chickens and risk infection and maybe even have a VERY sick member living with them, but decide to keep it on the down low as to not lose their ’livelihood’ as you put it. I’d rather they slaughtered the chickens.
These are very simple minded people, and most of the time, will not follow any kind of instructions coming from any official source like the government. The proof of which is that as i said, people are still dying. A little girls just died a couple of days ago because she came in contact with infected birds.
2 Stars
Hemant
Varanasi, India
Why not just test the pigs, instead of killing them? I don't agree with PETA but unless the pigs are infected and threaten us, why kill them? People are so quick to destroy animals.
1 Stars
Test the pigs? Hermant, you’re talking about a country that BARELY values human life!! you want them to test 300,000 pigs? hahaha...seriously?
1 Stars
Jeanelle
Calgary, Canada
Ludicrous. The country doesn't have a single case of swine flu and they haven't even tested the pigs. In the countries which do have human cases, only one country has reported deaths. This is just rampant paranoia and third world thinking.
1 Stars
Nuya Bidness
Birmingham, United States
I totally understand the viewpoint of the OP here. The whole world pondered why would the Egyptian government do such thing. It seemed to be a knee jerk reaction but it would have exposed the mediocrity of the Egyptian health care system.

Now, I have been to pig farms in the US, they are lovely, pastoral places with huge barns with concrete floors, and automated feeding troughs and sprinkler systems in the ceiling that keep the pigs washed. There are adorable little pink piggies that are checked over by veterinarians and almost no smell at all.

The video I saw of the pig farms in Egypt are nothing like that. From a sanitation stand point, those were a breeding ground for all sorts of diseases, not just flu. Maybe this will be the impetus for dealing with garbage in a more effective way.
Add your Comment